Games like Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy
by Broken Arrow Games
Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy, is an introduction to the dramatic story of a boy kidnapped by a psychopath. Exploring the giant house of your torturer you will soon discover things worse than your childish nightmares. Take on the role of Jamie and see what phrase “The First Toy” actually means.
View on Steam · Free →
Ranked by how similar the games actually are, not by sales. Released and Price are remembered for next time.
Closest matches
$4.00Zort
Dec 7 · Londer Software
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
Zort is an action, adventure, and horror game that can be played with up to 4 people. Explore maps with your friends and have fun while escaping from various creatures. Experience a realistic horror experience with in-game voice chat with your friends!
Early AccessHorrorOnline Co-OpCo-opFunnyPsychological HorrorFirst-PersonPvEAtmosphericAction👍 11,741
-20%$7.99Escape the Backrooms
Oct 23 · Fancy Games, Blackbird Interactive
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
Escape the Backrooms is a 1-4 player co-op horror exploration game. Traverse 30+ eerie backrooms levels while avoiding entities and other dangers. Try to escape but be warned: survival isn't guaranteed.
HorrorMultiplayerOnline Co-OpPsychological HorrorCo-opSurvival HorrorFirst-PersonEscape RoomExplorationAdventure👍 137,469
$29.99Sons Of The Forest
Feb 22 · Endnight Games Ltd
Both: Co-op · Horror · First-Person
Sent to find a missing billionaire on a remote island, you find yourself in a cannibal-infested hellscape. Craft, build, and struggle to survive, alone or with friends, in this terrifying new open-world survival horror simulator.
SurvivalOpen WorldMultiplayerCo-opSurvival HorrorBase BuildingHorrorCraftingBuildingFirst-Person👍 284,737
$19.99The Scourge | Tai Ương
Mar 28 · Rare Reversee, Beaztek
Both: Horror · First-Person · Realistic
Explore the nightmarish lucid dreams of Nhat Huy to solve his family's mystery. Set in 90s Saigon, navigate dilapidated corridors, solve mind-bending puzzles, and uncover sinister secrets. Can you survive the twisting maze and The Scourge?
HorrorSingleplayerSupernaturalMultiple EndingsExplorationFirst-PersonIndieRealisticAdventurePuzzle👍 1,195
$7.99DON'T SCREAM
Oct 28 · Digital Cybercherries
Both: Horror · First-Person · Realistic
If you scream, you restart. A jumpscare horror simulator where you walk through a pitch black forest and escape by reaching 8:00 AM.
Psychological HorrorHorrorAtmosphericFirst-PersonWalking SimulatorJump ScareVoice ControlExplorationMysteryRealistic👍 4,507
-35%$6.49R.E.P.O.
Feb 26 · semiwork
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
An online co-op horror game with up to 6 players. Locate valuable, fully physics-based objects and handle them with care as you retrieve and extract to satisfy your creator's desires.
HorrorOnline Co-OpMultiplayerComedyCo-opPhysicsFirst-Person3DStealthSurvival👍 341,331
$39.99The Outlast Trials
Mar 5 · Red Barrels
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
Red Barrels invites you to experience mind-numbing terror, this time with friends. Whether you go through the trials alone or in teams, if you survive long enough and complete the therapy, Murkoff will happily let you leave… but will you be the same?
HorrorMultiplayerCo-opSurvival HorrorPsychological HorrorFirst-PersonPvEStealthCharacter CustomizationAction👍 91,046
$9.99NO BACKUP
May 9 · Serundeox
Both: Horror · Realistic · First-Person
Escape together or die alone. A relentless creature is hunting you in this intense co-op bodycam horror experience. Communicate. Stay quiet. Survive. Every move matters. Every sound could be your last. Made by one developer.
HorrorFPSOnline Co-OpMultiplayerPsychological HorrorActionRealisticFirst-PersonSurvival HorrorShooter👍 893
-66%$8.49Autopsy Simulator
Jun 6 · Woodland Games
Both: Gore · Horror · First-Person
Autopsy Simulator is a first-person horror-sim hybrid where players take on the role of a practice pathologist and study case files, created in collaboration with real-world forensic doctors, to help guide their dissection of anatomically accurate bodies to determine each subject’s cause of death.
SimulationIndieNudityGoreHorrorMedical SimFirst-PersonRealisticPsychological HorrorSingleplayer👍 1,339
$7.99Backrooms Media
Dec 16 · NPK Games
Both: Co-op · Horror · First-Person
Backrooms Media is a 1-4 player co-op horror that plunges you into unsettling, hyper-realistic liminal spaces. Navigate eerie environments filled with lurking horrors. Group up with your friends to face the terror of the endless backrooms together and... try to escape.
Co-opMultiplayerCasualPsychological HorrorHorrorOnline Co-OpSurvival HorrorFirst-PersonExplorationSingleplayer👍 546
-50%$2.49Dollmare
Oct 24 · Alex Grade, gonzeek, Oxeren
Both: Horror · First-Person
You've accepted a shady job offer at a doll factory. Inspect dolls for defects and anomalies. Follow strange protocols. Don't get fired and stay alive.
SimulationHorror3DPsychological HorrorFirst-PersonSupernaturalControllerWalking SimulatorMultiple EndingsLinear👍 2,047
$9.99PANICORE
May 31 · ZTEK Studio
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
PANICORE is a survival horror game that mixes permadeath, AI monsters and a co-op experience up to 5 players (4 players in demo). Try to escape and don't get caught, but beware: they don't only hear your steps, but also your voice.
HorrorOnline Co-OpSurvival HorrorPsychological HorrorCo-opMultiplayerFirst-PersonPvEStealthAtmospheric👍 10,746
$39.99REANIMAL
Feb 13 · Tarsier Studios
Both: Horror · Co-op
The creators of Little Nightmares™ I & II have returned to take you on a darker, more terrifying journey than ever before. In this horror adventure game, a brother & sister go through hell to rescue their missing friends and escape the island that they used to call home.
HorrorCo-opAdventureMultiplayerAtmosphericDarkLocal Co-OpPuzzle3DThird Person👍 13,825
$6.99Nuclear Nightmare
Oct 20 · BG Productions
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
Venture forth as part of a specialized team of fellow players tasked with retrieving classified materials, evading the black goo virus, and the nightmarish entities it has spawned. With time running out before the US government initiates a devastating nuclear strike to contain the spreading menace.
Online Co-OpSurvival HorrorHorrorCo-opFirst-PersonPsychological HorrorMultiplayerAtmosphericExplorationOpen World👍 15,409
$5.99Zoonomaly
Mar 6 · LIGHTS ARE OFF LLC
Both: Horror · First-Person · Realistic
You must survive a monster infested zoo while searching for key shards that unlock the truth to its origin. Collect all the key shards by solving puzzles throughout the grounds and put a stop to the monster mayhem.
HorrorExplorationPuzzleOpen WorldAction-AdventureFirst-PersonRealistic3DActionController👍 945
$9.99KLETKA
Feb 19 · Callback, ln404
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
KLETKA is a co-op (up to 6 players) horror game about going down in an elevator that is trying to eat you. Feed the elevator, explore deadly floors and descend deeper.
HorrorCo-opOnline Co-OpFirst-PersonPvEActionAdventureRoguelikeAction-AdventureDungeon Crawler👍 6,376
-80%$0.99Eyes: The Horror Game
May 20 · Fearless Games
Both: Horror · First-Person
You break into the mansion at night. It’s huge and built like a maze. You're trying to escape, but the monster is after you! The chase begins. RUN!!
AdventureHorrorSurvival HorrorExplorationDarkPuzzleSimulationDemonsInteractive FictionFirst-Person👍 932
$4.99Don't Shout Together
Jun 14 · SinisterGames
Both: Horror · First-Person · Co-op
If you scream, you and your entire team will die. You need to leave the dangerous forest before the timer runs out by either assembling a car or calling the police. If the set time expires, the entire team will perish. Time progresses when you move. Don't make the team wait for you!
HorrorExplorationActionAction-Adventure3DMultiplayerFirst-PersonPsychological HorrorCo-opLinear👍 470
$7.99Supernormal
Jan 8 · Hitori de Productions
Both: Horror · First-Person · Realistic
Inspired by Allison Road. SUPERNORMAL is a psychological horror game set in a seemingly ordinary apartment harboring dark secrets. Play as Detective Wyatt, tasked with unravelling the disappearance of Masato Sakamoto's daughter. Search for clues and unravel the sinister truth.
HorrorFirst-PersonPsychological HorrorSupernaturalSurvival HorrorRealisticDetectiveMysteryDarkAtmospheric👍 1,119
$7.99The Headliners
Jan 30 · KAFI
Both: Horror · Co-op · Gore
Co-op horror game where you play in teams of 1 to 8 reckless journalists, ready to explore a city overrun by deadly creatures to snap spectacular footage. Your only goal: make the headlines without becoming one.
Online Co-OpHorrorCo-opFunnyMultiplayerActionIndieAction-AdventureTeam-BasedGore👍 8,539
$9.99GONE Fishing
Jun 15 · GONE Studios
Both: Horror · First-Person · Co-op
GONE Fishing is a 1-8 player survival horror game where you and your friends must work together to stay alive, by fishing. The only way to survive is to keep feeding the lake’s insatiable hunger before it feeds on you. Can you satisfy the hunger... or will you become the next offering?
ActionAdventureHorrorMultiplayerFishingOnline Co-OpFirst-PersonCo-op3DAtmospheric👍 3,018
$9.99SILENT BREATH
Aug 20 · EXODIAC STUDIOS
Both: Horror · Realistic · First-Person
Unpredictable horrors lurk around every corner, forcing you to find the missing people while desperately clinging to survival. In this experience even your own mind can become your enemy. Stay vigilant and keep your voice hushed, or risk becoming another victim of the forest's darkness
HorrorPsychological HorrorThriller1990'sRealisticMultiplayerDarkFirst-PersonExplorationEarly Access👍 1,125
$9.99The Devourer: Hunted Souls
Oct 26 · ZTEK Studio
Both: Horror · Realistic
Play as a paranormal investigator in our hybrid between first person survival and psychological horror story game. Investigate a haunted forest with up to 5 players CO-OP, try to lift the curse, experience a tragic story and take decisions together. Will you survive or will you lose your soul?
Early AccessHorrorMultiplayerSurvival HorrorOnline Co-OpVRCo-op CampaignPsychological HorrorRealisticInvestigation👍 506
$13.99Blood Hunting
Oct 27 · Holcomb Entertainment LLC
Both: Horror · First-Person · Violent
Blood Hunting is a first-person survival horror game by Holcomb Entertainment. A true survival horror experience that sets the stage on how dangerous revenge can be... if you can survive it.
HorrorPsychological HorrorSurvival HorrorFirst-PersonDarkAtmosphericViolentGoreSurvivalAction
$19.99Evil Nun: The Broken Mask
Dec 7 · Keplerians, Carlos Coronado
Both: Horror · First-Person · Violent
Enter Evil Nun's nightmare. Trapped in a cursed school, escape from Sister Madeline. She's cunning, searching every corner, luring and talking to you depending on your actions. Solve puzzles, craft items, and uncover the mystery in this horror game with different escape routes.
HorrorSurvival HorrorStealthFirst-PersonViolentArtificial IntelligenceAtmosphericPsychological HorrorAdventureVillain Protagonist👍 1,085
$9.99Project Unknown
Oct 10 · PsychoRavens
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
An online co-op horror game featuring unique playable characters and RPG mechanics. Exorcise ghosts using your special abilities and tools while surviving the supernatural onslaught
HorrorOnline Co-OpMultiplayerPsychological HorrorCo-opSurvival HorrorDarkFirst-PersonInvestigationSupernatural👍 776
-40%$0.59The Butterfly Collector
Feb 9 · Wicky Yu
Both: Horror · First-Person · Gore
investigate the evidence left by a stalker and kidnapper and track the fate of a college girl. The player advances and watches the plot by clicking to make choices for the heroine at key moments, with different choices leading to different endings.
Visual NovelWord GameAdventureHorrorPsychological HorrorFemale ProtagonistSingleplayerFirst-PersonText-BasedGore👍 936
$3.99Psalm 5:9-13
Mar 13 · N4bA, Notex, a1esska
Both: Horror · Gore · First-Person
"Psalm 5:9-13" is a first-person psychological horror game with VHS effect. Be careful and attentive, there is something hiding in these rooms, something is watching from the darkness.
Psychological HorrorHorrorIndieExplorationMysteryWalking SimulatorGoreAtmosphericFirst-Person3D👍 1,851
$14.99Hollow Cocoon
Dec 6 · NAYUTA STUDIO
Both: Horror · First-Person
"Trapped in a cocoon, the silkworm weaves her final dream." Hollow Cocoon is a first-person horror adventure game set in 1980s Japan. Immerse yourself in meticulously recreated environments as you venture into the depths of unspeakable horrors that await you.
HorrorPsychological HorrorAdventureSurvival HorrorDarkMultiple EndingsStealthFirst-PersonIndieAtmospheric👍 865
$6.99Dolls
Dec 20 · Fake Fox
Both: Horror · First-Person
Dolls is a first-person horror game in which the player must escape from a dark school inhabited by seemingly lifeless dolls. Confront your fears, unravel the mysteries, and survive this suffocating environment in order to return to reality.
HorrorPsychological HorrorExplorationSurvival HorrorFirst-PersonDarkAction-AdventureDungeon Crawler3DPost-apocalyptic
$29.99No More Room in Hell 2
Aug 11 · Torn Banner Studios
Both: Co-op · First-Person
No More Room in Hell 2 is an intense 8 player zombie shooter. Overcome the endless undead. Avoid infection. Survive hell together.
ZombiesMultiplayerOnline Co-OpCo-opSurvival HorrorActionSurvivalFPSFirst-PersonIndie👍 16,843
$9.99Spectral Scream
Aug 28 · STOIC Ent.
Both: Co-op · Horror
Spectral Scream is a 1-4 player cooperative horror exploration game. Are you ready to face death in the maw of purgatory? Your goal is to find key items in each chapter and retrieve the orb. But be careful! Threatening and vicious creatures await you at every stage.
Online Co-OpCo-opHorrorMultiplayerPsychological HorrorThrillerDemonsSurvival HorrorLogicPuzzle👍 653
$3.99Paragnosia
Oct 24 · Sine Coda
Both: Horror · First-Person · Realistic
Observe every corner of your apartment by moving your camera along a rail that runs through the rooms. Find and take pictures of paranormal anomalies to exorcise them. Locked in your surveillance room, will you survive tonight's 8 rounds?
Psychological HorrorHidden ObjectAtmosphericHorrorStealthPuzzleFirst-Person3DTime ManipulationRealistic👍 229
$9.99Whispers in the Void
May 7 · Anri Khachaturov, Artur Manukyan, Arman Petrosyan
Both: Horror · First-Person · Realistic
The main hero John Eikts wakes up in a mysterious room for supernatural creatures. Anomalies escape, wreaking havoc. Eikts must navigate the chaos while uncovering his dark past. As he approaches freedom, a shocking twist reveals that he is not a victim, but one of them.
AdventureHorrorSurvival HorrorPsychological HorrorPuzzleWalking SimulatorExplorationHidden ObjectFirst-PersonRealistic
$9.99Garten of Banban 7
May 10 · Euphoric Brothers
Both: Horror · First-Person
Explore the monster-occupied levels of Banban’s Kindergarten. Survive the dreads that reside below as you are now completely on your own. Uncover the truth behind the place, and find the whereabouts of your missing child…
HorrorSingleplayerFirst-PersonPuzzlePsychological HorrorCartoonyActionDark3DSurvival Horror👍 1,549
$17.99Folklore Hunter
Jan 30 · Liquid Donkey Games
Both: Horror · Violent
You’re a world-renowned hunter of supernatural beasts. Track down urban legends from all over the world, set traps, solve disturbing puzzles, and defeat the beasts before you succumb to their otherworldly presence.
HorrorMultiplayerSurvival HorrorOnline Co-OpPsychological HorrorViolentEarly AccessMythologyHuntingFPS👍 1,217
$2.99Unknown Host
May 9 · Redsroll
Both: Horror · First-Person · Realistic
It's a short indie horror game where we step into the shoes of Alex, a student who, in search of more comfort, rents an apartment in the city that, at first glance, seems pretty decent — but upon arrival, he realizes something is not right.
HorrorAtmosphericPsychological HorrorExplorationWalking SimulatorFirst-PersonDarkIndieRealisticGore
$4.99Twelve Sticks
Sep 25 · Beshbarmak games
Both: First-Person · Realistic
Play hide-and-seek with friends online, hide from the monster, or play as a monster and catch other players. Get scared, have fun, collect points, buy upgrades, and most importantly, have fun.
Early AccessSimulationActionWalking SimulatorHidden Object3DFirst-PersonRealisticColorful1990's
-25%$3.74ZonZon
Aug 15 · Paphnutius
Both: Horror · Realistic · First-Person
The main character is a journalist who arrived at a large warehouse to record a documentary about the warehouse operation. But instead, he is faced with a real nightmare. The warehouse turns out to be populated by hungry guards and crazy warehouse operators who turn it into a death trap.
Psychological HorrorParody HorrorFunnyRealisticWalking SimulatorEducationActionFirst-PersonConspiracy
$29.99Crime Scene Cleaner
Aug 14 · President Studio
Both: First-Person · Gore
Once you get tangled with the mob, you will forever be a part of the mob. At least they pay a decent salary and all you have to do is clean up after their dirty work, but you know what you’re doing. So clean crime scenes, earn as much money as you can, and get ready for the next mission.
SimulationCrimeSingleplayerRelaxingFirst-PersonGoreAtmosphericCleaningFunnyAction👍 32,497
$4.99Midway accident
Jul 8 · Tactical penguin
Both: Realistic · Horror · First-Person
This is a multi-person survival and escape game. You need to find what you need in the game. You can choose to leave immediately after finding what you need, or explore what happened in this area.
Survival HorrorExplorationSurvivalRealisticAtmosphericHorrorFirst-PersonInvestigationCraftingStrategy
-50%$5.99Doll Impostor
Mar 28 · David Gallardo
Both: Horror · First-Person
Doll Impostor is a horror game where 1-4 players take on the role of guardians of possessed dolls. Work together to identify the impostor doll before 9 a.m, or face dire consequences. Every hour counts in this tense, fear-filled race against time.
StrategyActionAdventureWalking SimulatorHorror3DCinematicFirst-PersonSingleplayerPsychological Horror👍 968
$14.99VIDeoPHOBIA
Mar 29 · Beshbarmak games
Both: Horror · Realistic
You are in a room without windows or doors. The TV dimly illuminates the room. What is this, a box? How to open it? After solving the riddle, you find the TV remote control. Click... a door appeared. You step into the darkness and hear laughter... turn around and find out what's behind the screen.
Psychological HorrorPuzzleHorrorPsychedelicPsychologicalAtmosphericRealisticStory RichMultiple EndingsExploration
$2.69A tale of terror
Oct 19 · Twisted Games
Both: First-Person · Realistic · Horror
A Tale of Terror isn’t just one horror game, it’s a chilling anthology. Each game delivers a unique and terrifying story that will keep you on the edge of your seat.
AdventureChoose Your Own Adventure3DFirst-PersonRealisticDetectiveDemonsHorrorPsychological HorrorSurreal
$6.99SCP: Descent
Mar 20 · Pixel Drip Games
Both: Horror · First-Person · Realistic
Inspired by SCP-087, step into the shoes of an unfortunate student long before the stairwell became legend. Follow the clues left by those who came before, your only choice is to descend.
HorrorPuzzleLovecraftian1980sAtmospheric3DActionFirst-PersonRealisticConspiracy👍 105
$6.99Backrooms Rec.
Mar 6 · Liminal Logic
Both: Horror · First-Person
Dive into the mysteries of the Backrooms with a solo-developed survival game. Explore eerie hallways, uncover secrets alone or in multiplayer (up to 6 players), and take on unique challenges.
MultiplayerOnline Co-OpSurvival HorrorHorrorChoose Your Own AdventureFPSFirst-PersonLocal MultiplayerPsychological HorrorAction-Adventure👍 1,832
$4.99Toy Scrappers
Mar 4 · LoudScream
Both: Horror · First-Person
Toy Scrappers is a thrilling chase-based horror game that can be played with up to 16 players. Some players take on the role of a killer attempting to capture others. Escape the madness and stay alive!
CasualHorrorMultiplayerOnline Co-OpPsychological HorrorThrillerActionSurvival Horror3DFirst-Person
-10%$9.90Poopy's Playland
3 days ago · EmilJoes Games
Both: Horror · First-Person · Realistic
Play as a grieving mother whose child went missing in a playland one year ago. Use your trusty flashlight to navigate through the dark, solve replayable puzzles to progress forward, and hide from the unstable killer mascots! Investigate the mysteries and find out the truth...
ExplorationPuzzleHorrorSurvival HorrorAction-AdventureFemale Protagonist3DFirst-PersonColorfulRealistic





