Games like Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy
by Broken Arrow Games
Don't Be Afraid - The First Toy, is an introduction to the dramatic story of a boy kidnapped by a psychopath. Exploring the giant house of your torturer you will soon discover things worse than your childish nightmares. Take on the role of Jamie and see what phrase “The First Toy” actually means.
View on Steam · Free →
Ranked by how similar the games actually are, not by sales. Released and Price are remembered for next time.
Closest matches
-80%$1.99Don't Be Afraid
Dec 17 · Limo Games, Broken Arrow Games
Both: First-Person · Horror · Gore
Don't Be Afraid is an adventure horror game, that allows you to personate a boy, kidnapped by a psychopath. You have to survive, escape and find out how you were kidnapped. Exploring the gigantic, mysterious house of your torturer, you will soon reveal many secrets, hidden inside it’s walls…
First-PersonHorrorSurvivalWalking SimulatorSurvival HorrorExplorationGoreStory RichSingleplayerSimulation👍 801
$9.99Backrooms: Escape Together
Oct 18 · Triiodide Studios
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
A visually lifelike co-op horror game for 1-6 people. Journey through 11 procedurally generated levels, using what's available to survive and progress deeper into the Backrooms.
MultiplayerHorrorOnline Co-OpPsychological HorrorSurvival HorrorCo-opAtmosphericFirst-PersonRealisticEarly Access👍 42,321
$19.99Dead by Daylight
Jun 14 · Behaviour Interactive Inc.
Both: Horror · Gore · Co-op
10 years of horror. 10 years of jump scares and close calls. 10 years of brutal sacrifices and thrilling escapes. Trapped forever in a realm of eldritch evil where even death is not an escape, four determined Survivors face a bloodthirsty Killer in a vicious game of nerve and wits.
HorrorMultiplayerSurvival HorrorGoreOnline Co-OpCo-opSurvivalTeam-BasedThird PersonViolent👍 685,627
$4.99Fear Therapy
Dec 24 · Black Flag Studios
Both: Horror · Co-op · Violent
Fear Therapy, is a multiplayer(1-4) and single player psychological horror game.Try to complete the quests and leave the horror house before it is too late! Satan getting angrier every second and nothing holding it back.
HorrorMultiplayerPsychological HorrorCo-opEarly AccessIndieViolentFirst-PersonSurvival HorrorDark👍 3,629
$4.00Zort
Dec 7 · Londer Software
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
Zort is an action, adventure, and horror game that can be played with up to 4 people. Explore maps with your friends and have fun while escaping from various creatures. Experience a realistic horror experience with in-game voice chat with your friends!
Early AccessHorrorOnline Co-OpCo-opFunnyPsychological HorrorFirst-PersonPvEAtmosphericAction👍 11,741
$3.99Chased by Darkness
Jun 1 · South Blue Moon
Both: Horror · Co-op · Gore
Chased by Darkness is a 1-4 players co-op survival horror. Your mission is to face supernatural entities and banish them to the spiritual plane. Explore, fight enemies and don't let the darkness reach you.
HorrorOnline Co-OpCo-opMultiplayerSurvival HorrorIndieActionGorePsychological HorrorFirst-Person👍 325
$15.99I am Weapon: Revival
Oct 23 · Krealit
Both: Gore · Violent · Co-op
Have you ever faced your worst nightmare? What if you have no choice but to move on and see what’s behind it? Then you’d better arm yourself with a couple of big guns, stock up on ammo and show them all what a real nightmare is!
ActionGoreIndieViolentTop-Down ShooterRPGCo-opShoot 'Em UpTwin Stick ShooterAdventure👍 241
FreePoppy Playtime
Oct 12 · Mob Entertainment
Both: Horror · First-Person
You must stay alive in this horror/puzzle adventure. Try to survive the vengeful toys waiting for you in the abandoned toy factory. Use your GrabPack to hack electrical circuits or nab anything from afar. Explore the mysterious facility... and don't get caught.
HorrorSingleplayerFree to PlayPuzzleFirst-PersonSurvival HorrorDarkPsychological HorrorMysterySurvival👍 38,443
$14.99Unforgiving - A Northern Hymn
Nov 27 · Angry Demon Studio
Both: Horror · Gore · First-Person
Unforgiving - A Northern Hymn is a first person horror game heavily inspired by Swedish folklore and the Nordic mythology to create the nightmares that's been haunting Swedish children for many generations.
HorrorIndieAdventureNudityActionGoreMythologyFirst-PersonViolentAtmospheric👍 1,437
-70%$5.09Paper Dolls: Original / 纸人
Apr 19 · Beijing Litchi Culture Media Co., Ltd.
Both: Horror · First-Person
Paper Dolls Original is a first-person horror adventure game steeped in Eastern culture. You act a man who is separated from his daughter after a car accident. When he awakes, he finds himself in a deserted Asian mansion. Find your daughter and unveil a terrifying story buried for a hundred years
HorrorAdventureThrillerActionPuzzleIndieMultiplayerFirst-PersonDating SimSingleplayer👍 4,451
$29.99Sons Of The Forest
Feb 22 · Endnight Games Ltd
Both: Co-op · Horror · First-Person
Sent to find a missing billionaire on a remote island, you find yourself in a cannibal-infested hellscape. Craft, build, and struggle to survive, alone or with friends, in this terrifying new open-world survival horror simulator.
SurvivalOpen WorldMultiplayerCo-opSurvival HorrorBase BuildingHorrorCraftingBuildingFirst-Person👍 284,737
FreeCry of Fear
Apr 25 · Team Psykskallar
Both: Horror · Co-op · First-Person
Cry of Fear is a psychological single-player and co-op horror game set in a deserted town filled with horrific creatures and nightmarish delusions. You play as a young man desperately searching for answers in the cold Scandinavian night, finding his way through the city as he slowly descends into madness.
HorrorFree to PlayPsychological HorrorMultiplayerSurvival HorrorCo-opAtmosphericPsychologicalFirst-PersonAction👍 296
$19.99Infliction
Oct 17 · Caustic Reality
Both: Horror · Gore · Violent
Wander through an interactive nightmare set within the confines of a once-happy household. Piece together the mystery behind a harrowing series of events while struggling to survive encounters with an entity that relentlessly stands in the way of finding absolution.
HorrorPsychological HorrorGoreAdventureIndieViolentAtmosphericSingleplayerWalking SimulatorStory Rich👍 826
$19.99Amnesia: The Dark Descent
Sep 8 · Frictional Games
Both: Horror · Gore · First-Person
Amnesia: The Dark Descent, a first person survival horror. A game about immersion, discovery and living through a nightmare. An experience that will chill you to the core.
HorrorGorePsychological HorrorSurvival HorrorAtmosphericPuzzleFirst-PersonNudityDarkLovecraftian👍 20,429
$14.99F.E.A.R. 2: Project Origin
Feb 12 · Monolith
Both: Horror · Gore · First-Person
Assume the role of Special Forces Sgt. Becket as your routine mission quickly turns into a fight for survival against the wrath of Alma Wade. As Alma's terrifying power surges out of control, your squad is forced to battle through an apocalyptic landscape in search of clues for how to destroy her!
HorrorFPSActionSingleplayerGoreMultiplayerShooterBullet TimePsychological HorrorFirst-Person👍 5,645
$4.99Five Nights at Freddy's
Aug 19 · Scott Cawthon
Both: Horror · First-Person
Welcome to your new summer job at Freddy Fazbear's Pizza, where kids and parents alike come for entertainment and food! The main attraction is Freddy Fazbear, of course; and his two friends. They are animatronic robots, programmed to please the crowds!
HorrorSingleplayerSurvival HorrorRobotsPsychological HorrorIndieDifficultPoint & ClickFirst-PersonDark👍 53,629
Also worth a look
Share some of the same DNA, but further from the original.

Paranormal Activity: The Lost Soul
Aug 15 · VRWERX
Both: Horror · Gore
AVAILABLE TO PLAY IN NON-VR (KEYBOARD/MOUSE AND CONTROLLER) VR HEADSET NO LONGER REQUIRED.“PARANORMAL ACTIVITY: THE LOST SOUL” immerses you in a terrifying realistic environment with haunting atmosphere, and the need to survive.
HorrorVRAdventureRPGSurvival HorrorPsychological HorrorGoreSingleplayerIndieMultiplayer👍 729
