PlayfeedGames like Pumpkin Eater
by thugzilladev
Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk and Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk play most like Pumpkin Eater. Of the 12 closest games below, most share its visual novel, psychological horror and horror; 6 are free or under $10. The best known is The Coffin of Andy and Leyley, with 36,717 Steam reviews.
View on Steam · $1.99 →
Ranked by how similar the games actually are, not by sales. Released and Price are remembered for next time.
Closest matches
Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk
Aug 26, 2020 · Nikita Kryukov
Both: Visual Novel · Psychological Horror · Horror
A short story about what sort of challenges everyday little things can be. Help the girl buy milk, be the first not to disappoint her.
Visual NovelPsychological HorrorHorrorExperimentalPsychologicalAbstractInteractive FictionText-BasedAdventureAnime👍 31,836Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk
Dec 16, 2021 · Nikita Kryukov
Both: Psychological Horror · Visual Novel · Psychological
A sequel to Milk inside a bag of milk inside a bag of milk. Dive into demented and bizarre world once again and help the girl become a little happier.
Psychological HorrorVisual NovelPsychedelicPixel GraphicsStory RichIndieMultiple EndingsPsychologicalAbstract2D👍 20,790Doki Doki Literature Club Plus!
Jun 30, 2021 · Team Salvato
Both: Psychological Horror · Visual Novel
Welcome to the club! Write poems for your crush and experience the terror of school romance in this critically-acclaimed psychological horror story.
Psychological HorrorVisual NovelAnimeDating SimSexual ContentCuteRomanceStory RichGoreMultiple Endings👍 30,319The Chrono Jotter
Aug 25, 2021 · Orca Layout
Both: Visual Novel · Horror
Rewind time to save your girlfriend in a twisted high school death game. A gripping yuri visual novel: Investigate brutal murders, unravel psychological horrors, and fight for a forbidden love that defies death itself.
Visual NovelFemale ProtagonistLGBTQ+IndieStory RichLovecraftianDetectiveAdventureAtmosphericHorror👍 1,969Cut to the Core
Jul 31, 2022 · Plasma Press
Both: Horror · Visual Novel · Hand-drawn
How much of someone can you cut away before there's nothing left? Find out in this chilling kinetic visual novel - IF YOU DARE!
HorrorStory RichVisual NovelLinearHand-drawnGoreComic BookInteractive FictionDarkStylized👍 160Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut
Oct 23, 2023 · Black Tabby Games
Both: Visual Novel · Psychological Horror · Horror
You're here to slay the princess. Don't believe her lies.
Visual NovelChoices MatterPsychological HorrorStory RichHorrorChoose Your Own AdventureRomanceHand-drawnLore-RichPoint & Click👍 32,195Scarlet Hollow
Jun 11, 2021 · Black Tabby Games
Both: Visual Novel · Horror · Psychological Horror
Your aunt’s dead, your cousin hates you, and you’re stuck in the dead-end town of Scarlet Hollow. Choose your path through a branching narrative so dense that you'll see less than 1/5 of the game on a single playthrough. You won't be able to save everyone. Good luck, and welcome home.
Early AccessChoices MatterVisual NovelHorrorPsychological HorrorStory RichDating SimMultiple EndingsInteractive FictionSupernatural👍 4,877The Coffin of Andy and Leyley
Oct 13, 2023 · Kit9 Studio
Both: Psychological · Visual Novel · Psychological Horror
Walk-n-talk adventure with light puzzling. Brother and sister practice cannibalism after witnessing a botched satanic ritual.
PsychologicalDark ComedyStory RichMultiple EndingsVisual NovelPsychological HorrorChoices MatterSingleplayerHand-drawnDark👍 36,717Iwaihime
Oct 23, 2020 · DMM GAMES
Both: Visual Novel · Psychological Horror · Horror
From hit writer Ryukishi07, the creator of When They Cry, comes a story on the theme of “curses.” Strike down the dark riddle of dolls and soot in this supernatural horror visual novel.
Visual NovelAnimePsychological HorrorSupernaturalAdventureAtmosphericHorror2DHand-drawnEmotional👍 864Higurashi When They Cry Hou - Ch.2 Watanagashi
Nov 13, 2015 · 07th Expansion
Both: Visual Novel · Horror · Psychological Horror
Higurashi When They Cry is a sound novel. The music, backgrounds and characters work together to create a world that is the stage of a novel for the user to read. They laugh and cry and get angry. The user takes the point of view of the protagonist to experience the story.
Visual NovelHorrorAnimePsychological HorrorMysteryStory RichDarkGreat SoundtrackPsychologicalGore👍 1,749