Games like Trident's Tale

Same developer and identical loop of sailing, naval combat, and exploring a pirate world.

Combines naval warfare and land exploration in a sandbox setting similar to your quest.

Offers deep naval warfare and trading, though with a more historical focus.

Captures that same feeling of managing a ship while exploring a vast new world.

Focuses heavily on ship-to-ship combat and boarding enemy vessels in the Caribbean.

Provides the ultimate pirate fantasy of sailing and looting, but in first-person.

Emphasizes tactical ship-to-ship battles and vessel customization over land combat.

Features real-time sailing and trading across many islands with various naval missions.

Delivers a whimsical pirate adventure with sailing and combat in a top-down view.

Focuses on survival and crafting while using your ship as a mobile base.

Features heavy emphasis on ship building and resource extraction in a water-covered world.

Swaps pirates for Vikings, but keeps the core loop of sailing and exploration.