PlayfeedGames like The Mystery of Oak Island
by Visionaire Studio UG
The Case of the Golden Idol and Tangle Tower play most like The Mystery of Oak Island. Of the 18 closest games below, most share its point & click, puzzle and mystery.
View on Steam →
Ranked by how similar the games actually are, not by sales. Released and Price are remembered for next time.
Closest matches
The Case of the Golden Idol
Oct 13, 2022 · Color Gray Games
Both: Mystery · Detective · Investigation
2D historical detective mystery puzzle, pixel graphics. Investigating crime scenes, deducing motives and killers, solving puzzles.
MysteryDetectiveInvestigationPuzzleConspiracyPoint & ClickStory Rich2DThrillerInteractive Fiction👍 9,805Crowns and Pawns: Kingdom of Deceit
May 6, 2022 · Tag of Joy
Both: Point & Click · Mystery · Puzzle
2D modern-day mystery point-and-click adventure, hand painted cartoony. Solving puzzles, exploring environments and making dialogue choices.
Point & ClickAdventureMysteryStory RichPuzzleFemale ProtagonistChoices MatterAtmosphericDetective2D👍 408The Roottrees are Dead
Jan 15, 2025 · Evil Trout Inc.
Both: Detective · Puzzle · Mystery
First-person 3D modern-day detective puzzle adventure, hand-drawn illustrations. Investigating evidence, solving puzzles and completing family trees.
DetectivePuzzleMysteryPoint & ClickInvestigationStory RichAtmosphericSingleplayer1990'sLogic👍 9,768Crowalt: Traces of the Lost Colony
Jan 6, 2022 · Madcraft Studios
Both: Mystery · Point & Click · Investigation
Side-view 2D historical point and click adventure, modern pixel art. Solving puzzles, investigating mystery and collecting artifacts.
Side ScrollerMysteryAdventurePoint & ClickStory RichInvestigationRetroPuzzleDetectiveHistoricalFollow the meaning
Nov 22, 2024 · HiKing Mind Studio
Both: Puzzle · Point & Click · Mystery
Isometric 2D point-and-click adventure, hand-drawn, surreal. Solving puzzles, investigating mystery and talking to citizens.
AdventurePuzzlePoint & Click2DHand-drawnMysteryMultiple EndingsIndieDetectiveSurreal👍 994Nancy Drew®: Curse of Blackmoor Manor
Oct 10, 2009 · HeR Interactive
Both: Exploration · Mystery · Puzzle
First-person 3D historical point-and-click adventure, detailed 3D graphics. Explore environments, interrogate suspects and solve puzzles.
ExplorationMysteryPuzzlePoint & ClickInvestigationFemale Protagonist2DDetectiveStory RichBased On A Novel👍 415Pentiment
Nov 14, 2022 · Obsidian Entertainment
Both: Investigation · Exploration · Mystery
2D historical narrative adventure, illuminated manuscript style. Investigating murders, making choices and exploring.
HistoricalStory RichInvestigationAdventureInteractive FictionHand-drawnStylizedExplorationMysteryMultiple Endings👍 9,252Desktop Explorer
Jul 17 · Recurring Dream
Both: Point & Click · Puzzle · Investigation
3D modern-day psychological horror mystery, retro-digital aesthetics. Investigating a missing person, solving puzzles and exploring a 90s OS.
Psychological HorrorPoint & ClickPuzzleInvestigationDetective1990'sSimulationMysteryInteractive FictionAdventure👍 2,157Maze of Thorns
Sep 29 · Fire Maple Games
Both: Point & Click · Puzzle · Mystery
First-person 2D modern-day point-and-click puzzle adventure, detailed atmospheric artwork. Solve puzzles, collect items and investigate mystery.
AdventurePoint & ClickPuzzleMysteryInvestigationCasualAtmosphericDetectiveFirst-Person2DPuzzle Agent
Jul 7, 2010 · Telltale
Both: Puzzle · Point & Click · Detective
2D modern-day point & click puzzle adventure, indie comic style. Solving puzzles, investigating mysteries and collecting hints.
PuzzlePoint & ClickCasualDetectiveInteractive FictionMysteryAdventureStory RichSingleplayerDark Humor👍 1,622Broken Sword - Shadow of the Templars: Reforged
Sep 19, 2024 · Revolution Software Ltd
Both: Point & Click · Mystery · Detective
2D modern-day point and click adventure, hand-drawn, cartoony. Solving puzzles, investigating mysteries and interacting with characters.
Point & ClickMysteryDetectiveInvestigationNarrativeDialogue HeavySingleplayerHand-drawnConspiracyCartoony👍 957The Samaritan Paradox
Apr 18, 2014 · Faravid Interactive
Both: Point & Click · Detective · Puzzle
Third-person 2D historical point & click adventure, hand-drawn pixel graphics. Solving mysteries, cracking codes and deciphering secrets.
AdventurePoint & ClickIndieDetectivePuzzleMystery2DPixel GraphicsSingleplayerStory Rich👍 166