Games like Pony Island
by Daniel Mullins Games
Pony Island is a 2D fantasy suspense puzzle horror: repair broken code, play arcade games and explore software systems. Inscryption and The Hex play most like Pony Island. Of the 12 closest games below, most share its horror, puzzle and psychological horror.
View on Steam · $4.99 →
Ranked by how similar the games actually are, not by sales. Released and Price are remembered for next time.
Closest matches
Inscryption
Oct 19, 2021 · Daniel Mullins Games
Both: Horror · Dark · Puzzle
First-person 3D fantasy deckbuilding roguelike psychological horror, inky, dark, surreal. Card battling, solving escape-room puzzles and deckbuilding.
Card BattlerCard GameStory RichDeckbuildingHorrorDarkPuzzleRoguelikeRogueliteStrategy👍 135,173The Hex
Oct 16, 2018 · Daniel Mullins Games
Both: Psychological Horror · Pixel Graphics · Dark
Side-view 2D psychological horror RPG, pixel graphics. Control six patrons, explore the inn and delve into memories.
IndieStory RichSingleplayerMysteryPsychological HorrorPixel GraphicsDarkFunnyGreat Soundtrack2D👍 4,497Fran Bow
Aug 27, 2015 · Killmonday Games AB
Both: Psychological Horror · Puzzle · Horror
Side-view 2D psychological horror adventure, hand drawn 2D. Solve puzzles, find objects and administer medication.
Psychological HorrorPoint & ClickStory RichPuzzleHorrorAdventureIndieDarkSingleplayerAtmospheric👍 20,630